Recipe Lists

19 Comforting Paleo Pumpkin Butter Recipes

Pumpkin butter is the perfect example of a vegetable—the humble and unpopular squash, at that—turned into a sweet and creamy treat no one would say no to. Fortunately, pumpkin butter is a confection that can easily be made paleo-friendly by using natural sweeteners like honey and maple syrup, the latter of which is perfect for fall flavors like pumpkin. Check out these paleo-friendly pumpkin butter recipes for pumpkin butter itself, as well as other treats using pumpkin butter as an ingredient.

If you have not tried pumpkin butter yet, you are seriously missing out! Here are 19 of my favorite recipes.


1. Simple Paleo Pumpkin Butter
Make this pumpkin butter in a saucepan with pumpkin puree, coconut oil, raw honey or maple syrup, ground cinnamon, ginger, cloves, and a pinch of salt. It’s rich and creamy, tastes like pumpkin pie, and can be used as a spread or an ingredient in other recipes.


30-minute Paleo Pumpkin Butter
Photo: Paleo Foundation

2. 30-minute Paleo Pumpkin Butter
The slow cooker versions are my jam, but if you need pumpkin butter for a recipe you’re about to make, you might not have 12 hours to spare. Try this delicious half hour version with coconut sugar, maple syrup, apple juice, lemon, pumpkin puree, and spices.


3. Crock Pot Paleo Pumpkin Butter With Vanilla Bean and Port
I love pumpkin butter made in the slow cooker—it’s so rich and tasty, and the other flavors in this one are fantastic. You’ll need pumpkin, ruby port, coconut sugar, maple syrup, vanilla bean, salt, black pepper, cayenne, and cinnamon. Put it on everything or eat it off a spoon. Yum.


4. Easy Homemade Apple Cider Pumpkin Butter
This pumpkin butter is sweetened with maple syrup and apple cider for a deliciously fall-perfect flavor, along with pumpkin pie spice and extra cinnamon and cloves. This recipe makes a smaller batch, so you can whip it up when you need it.


5. Lightened Up Raw Pecan Pumpkin Butter
This thick pecan pumpkin butter makes a perfect dip for fruits and veggies, but it’s tasty enough with vanilla, coconut oil, maple syrup, and spices that you’ll enjoy it spread across the top of paleo bread, paleo muffins, or delicious paleo waffles for breakfast.


Chocolate Pumpkin Butter Cups
Photo: My Heart Beets

6. Chocolate Pumpkin Butter Cups
Who says you need nuts to make chocolate nut butter cups? This healthy and nut-free, allergy-friendly version uses chocolate chips, coconut oil, pumpkin pie spice, nutmeg, sunbutter, pumpkin puree, honey, and more pumpkin pie spice. They’re so good.


7. Pumpkin Butter Cinnamon Rolls
This fun recipe is for deliciously buttery pumpkin butter cinnamon rolls, with pumpkin in the roll, the filling, and the topping. So much pumpkin, so much goodness. The recipe even provides two different frostings—one with cream cheese, and one dairy-free. Yum!


8. Sea Salt Pumpkin Butter Cups
I love the refined flavors of this version of pumpkin butter cups, with dark chocolate, crunchy almond butter, pumpkin puree, pumpkin pie spice, honey, and coarse sea salt for the top. The flavor combo of pumpkin and almond butter is absolutely heavenly.


9. Maple Pumpkin Butter
Maple and pumpkin are comfort flavors, and they make me think of cozying up by the fire with a mug of hot apple cider or hot chocolate and enjoying something tasty and pumpkin-filled. Whatever it is, I’d want to top it with this maple pumpkin butter.


Pumpkin Butter Waflfes With Maple Cinnamon Glaze
Photo: From Jessica’s Kitchen

10. Pumpkin Butter Waflfes With Maple Cinnamon Glaze
This recipe takes a few modifications, but when you replace the brown sugar with coconut sugar and use powdered coconut sugar in the glaze (or leave it out), you’re left with an awesome recipe for paleo pumpkin butter waffles and a yummy drizzle


11. Simple Crock Pot Apple Pumpkin Butter
Made with just a third of a cup of palm sugar as the sweetener, this tasty apple and pumpkin butter happens all in your crock pot and is full of delicious flavors from lots of spices, like cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, cloves, and a more unusual addition-cardamom.


12. Cinnamon Apple and Pumpkin Butter Custard Muffin Cups
Custard is a delicious breakfast, in my opinion. It’s warm, creamy, sweet, and filling, so it’s yummy way to start the day—especially if you enjoy it in the form of these apple and pumpkin butter custard cups, made with applesauce, pumpkin butter, almond milk, cinnamon, and more.


13. Maple Spice Squash Butter
This isn’t exactly pumpkin butter, but it’s a fun twist I wanted to include to get your imagination going. Use a pumpkin butter process with vanilla, cinnamon, maple, and more, but make it with roasted butternut squash instead of pumpkin. It’s delicious!


Superfood Pumpkin Butter
Photo: Nutrition Stripped

14. Superfood Pumpkin Butter
Filled with maple syrup, chia seeds, pumpkin pie spice, vanilla extract, ground cinnamon, and sea salt, This good-for-you pumpkin butter tastes like pure autumn bliss and is tasty on everything from paleo toast to paleo hot cereals, or just on apple slices!


15. Pumpkin Butter Alfajores
Alfajores are a traditional South American cookie usually made with cornstarch—for this recipe, replace the cornstarch with arrowroot starch and leave out the whiskey (unless you want to leave it in!) to enjoy these deliciously crispy, pumpkin butter-filled cookies.


16. Grain Free Pumpkin Pie Cookies
These cookie taste just like pumpkin pie, from the shortbread-style outer layers to the creamy pumpkin butter filling. You’ll need almond, coconut, and tapioca flours, honey, vanilla, butter, cinnamon, and a few other typical cookie ingredients.


17. Pecan Pumpkin Butter
This recipe is sweetened with just stevia and a hint of honey, so you can enjoy it without guilt! Make it with a milk of your choice, pumpkin puree, cinnamon, pumpkin pie space, vanilla extract, stevia, honey, and sea salt. Put it on everything.


Simple Pumpkin Butter
Photo: Crave the Good

18. Simple Pumpkin Butter
This recipe needs nothing but pureed pumpkin, honey, pumpkin pie spice, cinnamon, and cloves. It keeps in the fridge for about two weeks, but if you use safe freezing methods, you could keep it in the freezer for much longer!


19. Apple Pumpkin Butter
With coconut milk adding healthy fats and a rich creaminess to this recipe, it’s the only apple pumpkin butter recipe you’ll ever need. And there’s no added sweetened! Just apples, pumpkin puree, coconut milk, pecans, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

1 Comment

Ask a Question 

  1. These pumpkin recipes look good. I already had the “Paleo Beginner’s Guide” & The “Paleo Sweets” Cookbook. My kitchen has been set up for many years now. If all the recipes look & taste this good, I’ll be happy!

Ask a Question/Comment

Facebook icon Twitter icon Instagram icon Pinterest icon Google+ icon YouTube icon LinkedIn icon Contact icon