The only thing better than a cookie is two cookies with something sweet and creamy in the middle. Am I right? Of course I am. So give these paleo sandwich cookie recipes a try, for grain-free, refined-sugar-free, dairy-free treats with fillings like frostings, cream, and ice cream!
1. Paleo Samoa Donut Ice Cream Sandwiches
Whether you call them Samoas or Caramel Delights, chances are good that you miss munching on them since going paleo. Problem solved! Try these paleo donuts that taste just like the Girl Scout Cookies, sandwiched around paleo-friendly vanilla ice cream.
2. Paleo Coconut Cream Pies
These coconut cream pies are amazingly chewy and delicious with a sweet, fluffy coconut vanilla cream filling sweetened with stevia. The cookies are made with coconut cashew butter and dates for an awesome flavor, and the finished product is perfect straight out of the freezer.
3. Lemon Coconut Cream Sandwich Cookies
Lemon and coconut are a lovely flavor combination with tangy tropical flavors, and if you stuff that lemon coconut cream between two vanilla cashew butter based cookies? Now we’re talking. These are sweetened with raw honey, which goes perfectly with lemon.
4. Healthy Paleo Cookie Dough Sandwich Cookies
What could be better than two paleo cookies surrounding a giant chunk of homemade cookie dough? Absolutely nothing. These are made with coconut flour, vanilla protein powder (use a paleo brand), sea salt, nut butter, maple syrup, and milk of choice with chocolate chips. So easy.
5. Double Chocolate Whoopie Pies With Toasted Hazelnuts
My husband and I hail from a part of the US where whoopie pies are traditional and generally sold to you by someone who drives a horse-and-buggy. Unfortunately, they’re loaded with sugar, so we haven’t had any lately—until now! These paleo whoopie pies are double chocolate with hazelnuts. So good!
6. Double Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches With Strawberry Coconut Cream
Strawberries and chocolate are a classic combination, and these double chocolate cookies are the perfect vehicle for that sweet strawberry cream. You’ll need yummy ingredients like butter, honey, vanilla, strawberries, coconut milk, almond flour, and chocolate chips.
7. Chocolate Hazelnut Sandwich Cookies
These essentially taste like Nutella in sandwich cookie form, but without the soy lecithin, refined sugar, and other yuckies. You’ll need some Swerve sweetened and hazelnut oil, but the other ingredients like butter and vanilla you probably already have in your kitchen.
8. Grain Free Sunflower Snickerdoodle Ice Cream Sandwiches
These cookies are deliciously sweet with just coconut sugar and flavors of vanilla and cinnamon. With lots of sunflower seeds and almond flour, they’re high in protein, too! Enjoy them rolled in cinnamon and coconut sugar and sandwiched with caramel coconut ice cream.
9. Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches
These ice cream sandwiches are made from grain-free, peanut-free “peanut butter” cookies and a molasses vanilla bean ice cream with a delicious flavor and the healthy benefits of grass-fed gelatin. The maple syrup is the perfect sweetener to accompany the molasses flavor.
10. Valentine Jam and Coconut Sandwich Cookies
With a homemade berry vanilla chia jam, these delightful cookies are sweet and simple. Flavors of vanilla beans, honey, and cardamom take the lead for the shredded coconut and hazelnut cookies, and you can use the leftover jam for other recipes.
11. Paleo Lemon Cream Sandwich Cookies
In this recipe, like lemon flour cookies sweetened with coconut sugar are combined with a coconut cream lemon filling for a double lemon, double amazing flavor. If you can keep them cold, these would be perfect for a spring or summer picnic dessert.
12. Lemon Curd Sandwich Cookies
Lemon curd is a perfect sandwich cookie filling because it’s thick and rich with a strong flavor that can carry milder cookies like this version, with ground almonds, tapioca flour or arrowroot, coconut oil, maple syrup, and vanilla. The lemon curd is vegan, which is a bonus for sharing with vegan friends!
13. Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches
Including a recipe for the ice cream as well as the cookies, these ice cream sandwich recipe is perfect for summer and perfect for enjoying with the kids—on the porch, so they can get all messy. And this chocolate ice cream is made with avocado, so you know they’re getting healthy fats!
14. Date Sweetened Chocolate Raspberry Valentine Cookies
Nothing says romance like the marriage of raspberry and chocolate, and these cookies are the perfect example. Make them with dates, almond flour, coconut milk, coconut butter, vanilla, and a homemade raspberry jam sweetened with maple or honey.
15. Sparkling Sandwich Cookies
This recipe is for simple almond flour, honey or maple sweetened vanilla lemon cookies you can fill with the fillings of your choice. Recommended are all-fruit jams or chia jams and homemade caramel or dulce de leche, paleo-style. Rolling them in coconut sugar makes them sparkle!
16. Chocolate Sandwich Cookies With Chocolate Cream Filling
Double the chocolate, double the delicious cookie goodness. This recipe starts with homemade chocolate wafer cookies made with coconut and arrowroot flours, cocoa powder, and coconut sugar. Fill them up with a chocolate cream filling made from cocoa powder, arrowroot, and maple syrup!
17. Vanilla Cookies With Creamy Chocolate Almond Filling
Chocolate and vanilla are a classic combo, made even more decadent with the addition of almond butter and cacao butter in the chocolate almond filling. This recipe is super simple, sweetened with raw honey and made rich with vanilla and butter.
Want more Paleo recipes? Take a look at the Paleo Grubs Book. With 470+ easy-to-prepare Paleo recipes in 17 comprehensive categories it is the only Paleo book you will ever need.
+ Make sure to sign up for our free newsletter to get our latest healthy recipes delivered weekly (it's free).